Intended Attraction
Chapter 4
Author — Sidia
I almost couldn’t believe my good fortune; here I was at my neighbours apartment with two gorgeous girls to play with—albeit with the caveat that I couldn’t enjoy both of them at the same time.
Not yet anyway.
What had begun as an accident with Jasmine and Alexis months before had morphed into an interesting experiment with intriguing results; I had successfully instilled an attraction within Hanna towards her teenage flatmate that was strong enough to overcome any moral qualms she might have otherwise held. It was obvious from Hanna’s reactions over the last few days that she had been trying to fight her growing lust, but it was equally as obvious that she was losing the battle.
Currently Sophie was laying face down on her bed with her ass in the air; I had blindfolded her and tied her hands behind her back—rendering her quite helpless. Her blushes and obvious embarrassment at her predicament—what I was doing to her being far outside her comfort zone—had spurred me on in my debasing of this innocent girl. And then, just after I had fingered Sophie into having an orgasm, I became aware that my gambit of leaving the door slightly ajar had paid off.
Hanna was standing just outside Sophie’s bedroom, peering in through the crack in the door. It wasn’t clear if she knew I had seen her—I didn’t know if she would even care if I had—but she certainly seemed utterly fixated upon the naked body of her young friend.
I slapped Sophie on her upturned buttocks and then slowly caressed the reddened skin of her ass. Sophie gave out weak moan in response—one that was softly echoed by Hanna. That wouldn’t do—I didn’t want Sophie hearing her older flatmate.
I wasn’t sure how far I could push this just yet, and I didn’t want to ruin it by Sophie suddenly realising that we had a voyeuristic audience. I knew that I could use my ability to drive both Sophie and Hanna into such a frenzy of desire that having sex with the both of them would be a sure thing; but I knew from long experience that something so sudden and out of the blue like that would have lasting ramifications. It would be the same situation that I had lived through time and time again throughout my life—freak outs and accusations would inevitably follow.
I had learnt a lot about my ability through my relationship with Alexis—as well as from other experimental encounters. If I had the patience and used my ability gradually, I could get around this problem. Of course, trying to get both Hanna and Sophie into bed was going to be tricky. Although I hadn’t had a plan when I had first used my ability to create an attraction to Sophie within Hanna, the possibilities had rapidly taken hold. I didn’t think Hanna would be a problem—in many ways her free-spirited take on sex and relationships would make things easier. And although I didn’t really know her very well yet, it was clear that she enjoyed her fair share of kinks in the bedroom.
No, Hanna was going to be easy. Hell, from the look of confused lust on her face right now, I was fairly certain she was only a small push away from climbing into bed with her teenage flatmate as it was. The part I wasn’t sure of yet was Sophie.
In the end I had decided to combine my strange desire to defile and sully the innocent teen with getting her into bed with Hanna. It was another experiment of sorts—I had been pulsing Sophie constantly at a low level with my ability the entire way through what I had been doing to her. If I could step her gradually into more and more depraved sex acts, then logically the end result of her ‘willingly’ having sex with another woman wasn’t out of the question.
The thought of working out a way to reliably have sex with multiple woman at the same time had lit a fire within me. I could do whatever I wanted with whoever I wanted if this worked. The possibilities seemed endless.
And in the meantime I got to enjoy myself with my two lovely neighbours.
To make sure that Sophie wouldn’t overhear Hanna, I moved around to the side table at the head of her bed where she had a lamp and an iPod connected to a small speaker. I switched it on to shuffle and then turned up the volume to drown out any inadvertent sounds—stroking Sophie’s hair softly to quiet down her questioning murmur.
I walked back around to behind Sophie and then ran my finger along her wet little pussy lips—more for Hanna’s benefit than anything else. At the same time, I pulsed my ability to deepen the arousal that Hanna was experiencing towards her friend. I gripped my cock and rubbed it along Sophie’s slit teasingly, and then slapped it on her upturned buttocks again.
Hanna audibly groaned at seeing what I was doing—the loudest noise she had made yet which made me think that she on some level knew what I was doing. Without trying to hide it or be subtle, I turned around to look at her just in time to see Hanna fumble with the front of her shorts. She swiftly unzipped them—letting them fall to the ground around her ankles—and then slipped a hand down the front of her panties; frantically beginning to masturbate. She still didn’t meet my eyes—all of her focus was on the girl on the bed.
Turning my attention back to Sophie, I placed my cock back at the entrance to her pussy. I had been playing and tormenting her for a while now, and had been achingly hard for almost as long. I let the head of my dick slip inside of her, sighing with pleasure at feeling how hot and tight she was again.
“Are you using protection?” Sophie asked me weakly over the music, her voice muffled from her being face-first into the mattress.
Out of the corner of my eye I saw Hanna bite her bottom lip and move her fingers under her panties even faster.
“I will in a minute, Sophie.” I said soothingly, sinking another half inch of my cock into the girl. I wasn’t planning on having unprotected sex with her, but I wanted to use this as an opportunity to exert more control over her. The more control she surrendered to me over her body the better. “I just want to feel you.”
“But—”
I pulsed Sophie with a solid wave of my ability.
“I will. I promise.” I said, grinning at the back of her head. I let my myself slide another inch deep, feeling her insides quiver and clamp down on me. “I want to feel you without a condom first. Then I’ll put one on.”
I pulsed her a second time.
“… okay.” Sophie said quietly.
“Thanks, Sophie.” I said, slapping her lightly on the side of her ass. I could see the tension in her shoulders, but at the same time she actually arched her back a little further—pushing her rear higher into the air for me.
I glanced back at Hanna—she was panting and squeezing one of her breasts through her shirt roughly while she played with herself. Clearly she was enjoying what I was doing to Sophie as well.
I gripped Sophie firmly by the hips and watched with pleasure as I inexorably pushed my cock all the way inside of her tight hole. She felt just as perfect as I remembered, and I sighed happily when my hips pressed against the soft flesh of her buttocks. I held myself buried all the way inside her—just savouring the moment.
“Okay, can you put a condom on now?” Sophie asked somewhat plaintively, raising her head to look sightlessly over her shoulder at me.
Instead of answering her straight away, I pulled myself out of her—the tight walls of her pussy gripping me all the while—until the head of my cock was once again resting right at her entrance. Then I pulsed her with the strongest use of my ability yet, and slammed myself all the way back inside.
Sophie arched her back violently and hunched her shoulders—pushing her face back into the mattress while crying out wordlessly. Her pussy was clamping down on my cock and I could see little shivers of pleasure running through her body.
Holding myself buried inside her again, I gently caressed the globes of her ass in a soothing manner. The initial shock over, Sophie was now whimpering quietly at being impaled on my shaft once more. I glanced back at Hanna to see her reaction—her mouth was hanging open and she was staring intently at us. She practically ripped her top in her haste to get it off of her body; now standing in the doorway in nothing but her sodden panties. She gripped and squeezed her heavy breasts freely now—unencumbered by her shirt—and sunk down onto her haunches; leaning back with her eyes half closed as she masturbated.
“Sorry, what did you say?” I asked Sophie innocently. I withdrew my cock again—holding it poised and ready. “I didn’t catch that.”
“Can—can you please put a—” She started to say, panting.
I sent another strong pulse through her body and slammed into her again—cutting off her words.
“Oh, god!” Sophie wailed loudly, her body going rigid once more. The insides of her pussy was rippling around my shaft.
“Missed it again.” I said softly, digging my fingers into her ass as I pulled out of her. “One more time, Sophie?”
“Condom—”
Pulse.
Slam.
Sophie let out a series of high pitched moans, and started orgasming around my cock—her pussy spasming deliciously. Her shoulders were shaking uncontrollably and small shudders rippled along her skin. I let her come down from the aftereffects of her climax for a few moments before taking pity on her.
“Thanks for letting me do that, gorgeous.” I said, trailing my fingers along her spine possessively. “Your pussy feels absolutely incredible, but I better put a condom on now.”
Sophie whimpered as I pulled out of her, collapsing in a limp heap on her bed. I don’t think she was fully aware of what exactly was going on now—which was perfect for what I had in mind next.
I walked over to Hanna and pulled the door fully open—looking down as I stood above her. She glanced up and met my eyes before quickly looking elsewhere. In that brief moment I saw all the turbulent emotions she was going through; they were plainly written all over her face. There was still shame there—but it was being overpowered by the arousal, lust, and excitement. She was on the verge of losing herself to it and I was going to have to be careful here.
I waited for her to make eye contact with me again but she seemed entirely focused on something else. With a grin, I realised that she was staring intently at my swinging dick above her. Hanna licked her lips as she took in the fact that my cock was still coated in her young flatmate’s juices.
When Hanna opened her mouth—whether to say something or not, I don’t know—I took the opportunity to push the head of my dick into her mouth. Her eyes opened wide but she immediately started sucking—her hand in her panties still desperately working on her sopping wet sex.
“Sorry about the taste.” I whispered, pitching my voice so that only she could hear. I pushed my cock deeper into her mouth, making her gag slightly. “I was just buried inside Sophie’s tight little pussy a few seconds ago.”
Hanna groaned around my shaft and started to suck my harder.
“Oh, you like the way it tastes?” I grinned. I used my ability to send another gentle pulse of attraction from her to Sophie. “What a depraved slut you are.”
I pulled my cock out of her mouth—ignoring Hanna’s whimper of protest—and roughly pulled her to her feet. I gripped a handful of her hair before leaning in and whispering right by her ear.
“I bet an over-sexed piece of ass like you has a few sex toys lying around her room, right?” She nodded and bit her lip. “Perfect. Go and get a vibrator and then come right back.”
I pushed her out of Sophies room, and watched her stumble for a moment before scurrying down the hallway to her own bedroom. I turned back to Sophie and knelt down by her head. I stroked her hair for a second before tilting her face towards mine. I kissed her gently and thoroughly—she pliantly and passively kissed me back; seeming too exhausted to do much more than react at this point.
Hanna arrived back, and edged her way hesitantly into Sophie’s bedroom. Her eyes darted all over the place but always ended back on the teen girl tied up on the bed. She was carrying a small, ridged, pink vibrator and I saw to some amusement that she had taken the opportunity to shed her panties. Now all three of us were naked in Sophie’s bedroom—even if Sophie didn’t know it.
I held my finger to my lips for silence, and walked over to Hanna—taking her by the arm and leading her around to behind Sophie. I took the vibrator from her limp hands, and placed it down by Sophie’s clit before turning it on.
“What —?” Sophie managed, raising her head weakly.
“Shh.” I said soothingly. I sent another pulse through her, making her shudder. “Relax and enjoy this.”
I ran the toy all over Sophie’s pussy, coating it liberally in the juices of her arousal. Her hips and buttocks clenched and twitched as I teased her sensitive sex, and soon I was drawing little yelps and strangled moans from her again. When the vibrator was shiny with Sophie’s juices, I turned it off and held it up before Hanna’s face before pressing it against her mouth.
Hanna shuddered with suppressed emotion, but parted her lips easily enough once I applied a bit more pressure. I pushed the toy inside, gently fucking her mouth with it; Hanna closing her eyes and starting to suck it clean of her young flatmate’s arousal.
There was almost a look of loss on her face when I took the toy out of her mouth and placed it once more at Sophie’s pussy. I turned it on and then slipped the entire thing inside of her, before beginning to pump it in and out of her in fucking motion. I kept it up for a few moments before taking Hanna’s hand and then placing it on the toy. She froze immediately—looking at me wild-eyed at suddenly finding herself touching Sophie so intimately. I carefully stepped aside before moving around behind Hanna; slipping my hands around her waist and groping her breasts while leaning forward and whispering softly into her ear.
“Fuck her.” I said quietly, sending a strong pulse of ability through her. “Fuck that pretty little pussy of hers. Make her cum.”
In an almost dreamlike state, Hanna started to thrust her own vibrator in and out of the unsuspecting Sophie’s pussy. I wondered what sort of turmoil was going though her mind right now—from what Sophie had told me, Hanna used to babysit her when she was younger, and yet now here she was molesting her without her knowing.
My cock was like an iron bar at watching Hanna fuck the toy in and out—Sophie was letting out quiet and exhausted sounding moans—and I had to get some relief. I carefully parted Hanna’s legs and walked her backwards a few steps—bending her forwards so that she could still reach Sophie on the bed. She was now almost at ninety degrees and was in the perfect position for me.
I eased my cock into Hanna’s pussy from behind, being careful to not interrupt her rhythm with the vibrator. She was incredibly wet, and while she wasn’t as tight as Sophie she still felt amazing around my shaft. I then started to gently thrust into Hanna—fucking into her steadily while she played with the oblivious girl on the bed before us.
I started to pulse Sophie at regular intervals—keeping her arousal going. Hanna I left alone—finally getting her hands on her teenage flatmate meant she was far gone enough that I didn’t have to do anything else. The only problem was that I couldn’t get the hard fucking rhythm that I craved—I didn’t want to let Sophie know it wasn’t me paying with her pussy—but on the other hand it was perverted and exciting enough that I almost didn’t care.
I reached around again and groped Hanna’s hanging breasts, digging my fingers into the soft flesh hard. She gasped and panted quietly as I whispered into her ear.
“Play with her ass. Finger-fuck her at the same time.”
Hanna shivered, but obediently licked a finger of her free hand before reaching out and placing the fingertip on Sophie’s exposed rosebud. In case Sophie noticed anything—Hanna’s fingers were a lot more slender than mine after all—I used my ability to send a prolonged pulse of arousal through the girl.
I fucked slowly and carefully into Hanna, watching over her shoulder as she eased her finger into Sophie’s ass at the same time as she fucked her with the vibrator. It was just so perfect and perverse that I could barely believe I was watching it happen. Sophie’s rate of breathing picked up as she once again felt herself being filled in both her pussy and ass at the same time—although this time the pleasure was increased by the sensations of the vibrator.
Without my having to say anything, Hanna eased another finger into Sophie’s rear to join the first. She started to finger-fuck the girl’s anus in time with the thrusting motions of the vibrator—panting so loudly now that if the music wasn’t still playing right by Sophie’s head there would be no way she wouldn’t have heard it.
I almost couldn’t believe it when I saw Hanna start to push a third finger into the tight opening. It was slow going now, and Sophie’s buttocks were clenching and unclenching rapidly—if I hadn’t been keeping up with the regular pulses I wasn’t sure she could have taken it.
“Oh god.” Sophie whimpered. “I feel so full.”
She was shaking her head and trembling wildly now. This was so outside the realm of her experience that it looked like she didn’t even know how to deal with it. And that was with her thinking it was me doing it to her! What would her reaction be if she suddenly realised it was Hanna who was doing this to her. Would she even care at this point?
This was just too hot; I needed more satisfaction that what I was getting by this slow and careful fucking.
I pulled out of Hanna while gently moving her out from behind Sophie’s quivering body. She didn’t want to go; hanging her head and resisting as I pulled her fingers out of the girl’s ass. I then took my place behind Sophie, and pulled the vibrating toy out of her pussy—handing it to Hanna, who took one look at it before wrapping her lips around it and starting to suck the juices off of it. Hanna then flopped down on the floor where she could get a good view of Sophie and I—spreading her legs wide and shoving the now clean toy deep into her own cunt.
I placed the head of my cock at the entrance to Sophie’s pussy before I hesitated. I had never actually got around to putting on a condom in the end. I absently rubbed the tip of my finger over the puckered rosebud of her anus while I considered whether to just starting fucking her tight pussy anyway. My fingertip slipped into her ass as I contemplated what to do—the ring of muscle weakened from so much abuse.
“Just stick it in.” Sophie muttered in a quiet and resigned voice.
“What?” I asked, genuinely surprised. She couldn’t mean …
I pushed my finger a little deeper into her rear to test her.
Sophie’s head nodded while a shiver ran through her naked body.
“Are you sure?” I pressed her.
“Just stick it in!” Sophie said in a louder voice. She sounded almost angry.
I shook my head in disbelief at the situation. Innocent little Sophie. Vulnerable with her ass in the air and so horny that she was actually telling me to fuck her in the ass. Still, it’s not like I wasn’t going to take her up on the ‘offer’. So, my cock still slick from being in Hanna’s pussy, I lined myself up with the girl’s ass and started to thrust in.
I groaned in pleasure as I started to ease my cock into Sophie’s ass. She whimpered some more, and buried her face into the mattress of her bed as I gradually invaded her bowels with my cock. Even though she had been stretched out quite a bit, my dick was quite a bit thicker than even three of Hanna’s slender fingers. Who, by the way, was watching me sodomise her young friend with great relish; fucking the sex toy into her pussy roughly as I took Sophie’s anal virginity.
I continued sending pulses of my ability into Sophie as I buried my cock in her rear passage. I wanted her to enjoy this—to look back and remember how much pleasure she felt at having a thick cock stretching her ass—to want to experience it again no matter what she actually thought about it.
I was breathing heavily when I managed to get all the way inside of her. It was so tight. So different. Even though I had barely started, I’d already made up my mind that I was going to try anal sex again.
I groaned again when I reversed and pulled out—her ass gripped my so tightly it was difficult to withdraw. It was easier to thrust back in the second time—Sophie whimpered and shivered as I bottomed out again. Then I started to fuck.
I gradually built up my pace and speed until I was smoothly sliding my cock in and out of Sophie’s ass at a decent pace—the slapping noise of skin on skin sounding out every time my hips met the rounded cheeks of her behind.
I admit I went a little wild—I had been on edge for quite a while by now, and as soon as Sophie’s ass had relaxed enough for me to properly fuck her, I took advantage of that fact mercilessly.
My whole world constricted down to the sensation of my cock sliding in and out of Sophie—what she was feeling becoming almost incidental in my regard. I was aware of Hanna gasping and moaning off to the side—she was clearly enjoying the show of me using her flatmate like this. There was no way I was going to last long like this.
I grunted loudly as my climax hit me abruptly and I started to spill my cum deep into her bowels. Completely on instinct, I flooded my ability powerfully into Sophie each time that I slammed into her and sent another spurt of my seed into her—making the girl cry out breathlessly as she started to spasm with the strongest climax she had experienced yet.
Sophie abruptly collapsed and went silent—going completely limp on the bed before me—my last few shuddering thrusts into her was like fucking a rag-doll.
After I recovered somewhat, I pulled my softening cock out of Sophie’s ass and went to check on her. Her breathing was steady and she appeared to be sound asleep—completely and utterly worn out. Even though I shook her a few times I couldn’t rouse her, so in the end I simply shrugged and put her to bed properly. I untied her hands and eased the blindfold off of her head, before covering her with a blanket.
I turned to Hanna and saw to my surprise that she was still fucking herself with the toy. Her eyes were hazy, and she looked almost deranged with lust. Even though I was fairly confident that Sophie was exhausted to the point where she wouldn’t wake up, Hanna was being loud enough that I deemed that it wasn’t worth the risk.
I gripped her by the arm and hauled her to her feet before marching her towards the door. Hanna didn’t want to leave, pushing against me futilely and moaning as she stared yearningly back towards Sophie’s peacefully sleeping form.
“No, I want —” Hanna almost whined.
“Quiet—you’ll wake her up!” I hissed, herding her out the door and towards the living room. I took the toy out of her hand and pushed her down onto the couch—putting a hand on her shoulder and leaning down over her so I could look her in the eyes. “She can’t know you were there.”
“But …” Hanna shook her head as if to clear it. She looked up at me with pleading eyes that were filling with tears. “What am I supposed to do!”
“Shhh—It’s okay. She’s not ready for you.” I said softly, sending a soft pulse through her. Some of the anguish left her face—being replaced with arousal and need. I reached down to place the vibrator between her legs and she parted her thighs obediently for me. “Not yet.”
“W-what?” Hanna stuttered, looking at me intently as the meaning of my words reached her. “Do you mean —”
“Trust me.” I said, smiling into her face. I eased the vibrator between the folds of her pussy and began to thrust it in and out. “Tonight was only the beginning.”
“Fuck.” Hanna raggedly breathed out. She clutched at my shoulders as she started to rock her hips forward in time to meet the thrusting toy. Her eyes were dilated and a deep flush was rising in her cheeks. “You promise?”
“I promise.” I whispered, ramming the vibrator faster and faster into her. “Soon you’ll be able to taste her. Not just second hand, but to run your tongue along her pretty little cunt.”
Hanna’s eyes rolled back in her head until only the whites showed, and she started shuddering uncontrollably as she came.